Living in Paris, I spent my first Thanksgiving dinner not on American soil. I can't recall what I ate, but it was not the traditional fare to which I was accustomed. (Actually, it was all the more disappointing because the meal wasn't very good at all... foodie that I am.) Regardless, I still spent the day with other Americans who recognized, knew, and, more or less understood the holiday and its customs, meanings, and implications.
This year, I found myself in the unique experience of needing to explain the history and cultural meanings of Thanksgiving to my non-American friends and fellow students. It was an interesting conversation, as I realized that the meaning of the holiday has shifted profoundly over the years. More than that, I also began to come to terms with the initial implications of Thanksgiving in its historical context, and that this was, supposedly, a friendly meeting of cultures, a change from the misunderstandings, conflicts, violence that characterized the relationships between the native Americans and the Pilgrim populations. In light of my studies in globalization, cross-cultural meetings, and changing cultural expressions, this seems an interesting and (probably? possibly?) unique shared experience, which the non-native American population has adopted as a tradition of community, sharing, and, implicitly, of Christian brotherly love. Not that I have time now, but it would be interesting to look into how Thanksgiving became the cultural phenomenon that it did, because I doubt that it was a smooth transition from year to year, as seems to be the case with many holidays.
These conversations also reminded me of my strong feelings towards the cultural misunderstandings between these populations, and the ensuing demonization of difference and violence. This was certainly one of the many times I was not quite proud of my American citizenship and history. However, I still identify myself as American, and, while I may be embarrassed of and frustrated by the government that has stolen my vote and made me look like the idiot ambassador of a cruel self-important and self-interested nation, there are things about the country and nation that I do enjoy having as part of my identity. Though I may not like the history of traditions such as Thanksgiving, it has become a tradition dear to my heart, (perhaps especially thanks to delicious whole-berry cranberry sauce), and a tradition in my family. Hopefully, I think that by acknowledging and accepting the problems of the past, I can move myself forward from that past to create a new future.
On a related note, I spent the day after Thanksgiving enjoying a Thanksgiving meal with my friends Vivian and Dan. I tried to make the effort towards tradition, and got a turkey leg, though we had to cook it in a pan, which was too slow, and we didn't get a chance to eat it.
It's the thought that counts, in these situations.


